Local, independent bookstores have never been as crucial as they are now. With the freedom to access literature under threat, these bookstores serve as a defense against censorship and greatly contribute to their communities.

Every week, we highlight an indie bookstore, exploring what makes it unique and sharing their expert book picks.

This week, we’re featuring Susan Buckmaster, a bookseller at The Taleless Dog Booksellers located in Berea, Kentucky!

Can you tell us about your store’s background?

After dreaming for 20 years of owning a small bookstore, the perfect opportunity finally arose, and we seized it. Without this ideal location, we may never have taken the plunge. Our bookstore is in a charming building over a century old. The name was inspired by our two tail-less dogs, and shortly after we opened, a tail-less stray cat found her way to us and decided to stay. Nora, our cat, has become quite the attraction, with many visitors coming just to see her. Once they enter, they quickly fall for the cozy charm of our bookstore.

The Taleless Dog’s goal is to inspire a passion for reading and curiosity. “We both grew up in book-filled households (back in the pre-internet days). Our families, though not affluent, ensured we had access to diverse books. We believe that reading is the foundation of learning. For children, we hope they discover their passion for reading here. For adults, we aim to offer books that continue that love,” explained Susan Buckmaster, co-owner alongside her husband, Clark.

What sets your independent bookstore apart?

Nora, the tail-less cat, is definitely our main attraction. People travel from afar just to meet her. Alongside our selection of books and book-related gifts, we believe we’re providing something that every community, big or small, needs—a warm, inviting bookstore with friendly staff and a fantastic book collection, sometimes with delightful treats! Our local books are particularly popular, drawing shoppers from Kentucky and beyond to browse this unique section.

What is your favorite section in the store?

I especially love our fantasy section. We stock an amazing range of fantasy books in one of the coziest areas of the shop, complete with cats and couches—what could be better?

Which book do you enjoy recommending to customers and why?

I love suggesting any book by Silas House. He’s a beloved local author, and his works are a hit with everyone. We recommend them to anyone in search of a good read.

What book do you believe deserves more recognition and why?

“1984” by George Orwell is a classic that we frequently sell. Its eerie relevance to today’s world in 2025 is unsettling, especially considering Orwell wrote it in the 1940s. While it’s a challenging read, it certainly pays off.

Why is it important to shop at local, independent bookstores?

Shopping locally ensures money stays within the community. It creates jobs, generates tax revenue, and strengthens community ties. When you shop in our store, you can touch the books, see their covers, and engage with real people. The experience of selecting books in person is incomparable to ordering online. In a bookstore, you engage all your senses. As part of Berea’s vibrant small business community, The Taleless Dog Booksellers advocates for local shopping. “Every book purchased here supports not only our store but also the very fabric of our community,” shares Clark.