Choosing the perfect used car can be challenging, especially when searching for a great deal on a reliable vehicle. Due to the increasing popularity of SUVs and trucks over the last ten years, there are fewer sedans, hatchbacks, and coupes available compared to previous years. To assist buyers looking for a quality used car priced below $10,000, we’ve put together this list of suggestions.

Our selection includes vehicles from the 2015-2018 model years, focusing on those with average or better reliability and strong safety ratings. We specifically looked for small, economical cars that boast impressive fuel efficiency. If you’re in search of a compact, affordable used vehicle, one of these options could be a perfect fit for you.

About MotorTrend’s Approach: The Buyer’s Guide understands the significance of purchasing a used car, which is why we take this process seriously. We recommend vehicles with multiple trim levels under the $10,000 price limit. To include a wider range of potential recommendations, we accepted models from 2015-2019. Additionally, we favor cars with Average or above scores in J.D. Power reliability ratings, while also taking into account safety evaluations from IIHS and NHTSA; while a five-star overall NHTSA rating isn’t mandatory, it is preferred.

2015-2017 Honda Fit: Subcompact Hatchback

Pros: It’s unfortunate that Honda has discontinued the Fit hatchback in our region. This subcompact vehicle stands out for its roomy interior, practicality, and enjoyable driving experience. The Honda Fit offers a manual transmission option and is notably fuel-efficient for a gasoline vehicle.

Cons: The entry-level infotainment screen is small, and features like Apple CarPlay and Android Auto were not available until the 2018 models. The manual version of the Honda Fit does not support Honda Sensing, which is a suite of active safety technologies.

The best AWD cars: Our top all-wheel drive recommendations in 2024

2015-2017 Honda Fit: Subcompact Hatchback

Specifications

• Approximate Price: Starting at $9,000
• Safety Ratings: 2015 IIHS Top Safety Pick, NHTSA 5 Stars overall
• Fuel Economy: 29-33/36-40 mpg city/highway
• Driving Range: 329-382 miles
• 0-60 mph Acceleration: 7.9-9.1 seconds

2015-2018 Kia Rio: Subcompact Sedan and Hatchback

Pros: The Kia Rio is available in both sedan and hatchback forms, bringing versatility to the table. It comes equipped with numerous features typical for a subcompact car, along with a solid build quality. Additionally, its fuel efficiency helps keep your fuel costs down. The 2018 Kia Rio EX also offers Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.

Cons: The Rio’s engine lacks power, and the steering feels somewhat disconnected, which diminishes the fun factor. Moreover, the rear seat is cramped, and the sedan’s trunk isn’t very spacious.

2015-2018 Kia Rio: Subcompact Sedan and Hatchback

Specifications

• Approximate Price: Starting at $6,000
• Safety Ratings: NHTSA 4 Stars overall
• Fuel Economy: 27-29/36-37 mpg city/highway
• Driving Range: 342-381 miles
• 0-60 mph Acceleration: 8.2-8.7 seconds

2015-2018 Chevrolet Sonic: Subcompact Sedan and Hatchback

Pros: The Chevrolet Sonic excels in its driving performance. With good acceleration, a smooth ride, and responsive handling, it makes a great choice for everyday use. The hatchback variant provides added utility with 19.0 cubic feet of cargo space. It also features a 7.0-inch infotainment screen equipped with Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Bluetooth functionality.

Cons: The base model of the Chevy Sonic can feel quite basic; it’s wise to look for a model with more features if comfort is a priority. Additionally, there aren’t many driver assistance options available, and manual versions have closely spaced gears.

2015-2018 Chevrolet Sonic: Subcompact Sedan and Hatchback

Specifications

• Approximate Price: Starting at $5,300
• Safety Ratings: 2015-2016 IIHS Top Safety Pick, NHTSA 5 Stars overall
• Fuel Economy: 24-28/33-38 mpg city/highway
• Driving Range: 342-390 miles
• 0-60 mph Acceleration: 8.1 seconds

2017-2018 Kia Forte: Subcompact Sedan and Hatchback

Pros: The Kia Forte boasts an appealing exterior and strong safety ratings, making it an attractive option. It includes a well-rounded selection of features and offers available driver assistance technology. The Forte can be equipped with a 7.0-inch infotainment screen that provides Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, an aux input, and Bluetooth audio streaming.

Cons: Some buyers may be deterred by its sluggish acceleration and stiffer ride. The interior design doesn’t stand out, either; it may not feel particularly premium compared to other compact options.

2017-2018 Kia Forte: Compact Sedan and Hatchback

Specifications

• Approximate Price: Starting at $6,000
• Safety Ratings: IIHS 2017 Top Safety Pick+, NHTSA 5 Stars overall
• Fuel Economy: 23-29/29-38 mpg city/highway
• Driving Range: 317-422 miles
• 0-60 mph Acceleration: 8.4 seconds

2015-2016 Toyota Corolla: Compact Sedan

Pros: The Toyota Corolla is well-known for being a reliable used car. It features excellent fuel efficiency, solid safety ratings, and a reputation for durability. Its exterior and interior designs remain timeless and attractive.

The design looks sleek and modern. There is ample room in the back seat, allowing adults to sit comfortably in the second row.

Drawbacks: The current generation of the Corolla isn’t particularly exciting to drive, with acceleration being one of its poorer attributes. Additionally, if you take a corner at speed, the seats lack adequate support. Neither of the model years offered Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.

2015-2016 Toyota Corolla: Compact Sedan

Key Specifications

• Approximate Price: Starting at $8,700
• Safety Ratings: NHTSA awarded it 5 stars overall
• Fuel Economy: 27-30 mpg in the city / 35-40 mpg on the highway
• Driving Range: 369-449 miles
• 0-60 mph Time: 9.2-9.7 seconds

Top Used Cars Priced Below $10,000

• 2015-2017 Honda Fit
• 2015-2018 Kia Rio
• 2015-2018 Chevrolet Sonic
• 2017-2018 Kia Forte
• 2015-2016 Toyota Corolla

Images provided by MotorTrend Staff and Manufacturer