Opinion: Russell Wilson’s Chance to Take Over as Steelers’ Starting QB Is Coming Soon
Time for recovery is essential.
That’s the current situation regarding Russell Wilson. The experienced quarterback participated fully in a Pittsburgh Steelers practice on Wednesday for the first time in weeks, as his stubborn right calf injury has improved. This raises the possibility that Coach Mike Tomlin might decide to start Wilson as early as this weekend, as the team (3-2) tries to break a two-game losing streak.
Although Justin Fields has outperformed expectations as the temporary quarterback, sparking discussions about whether 35-year-old Wilson will ever be the starter, it’s a classic quarterback debate. This discussion gained traction soon after Wilson’s injury at the start of training camp in July, while Fields showcased his potential.
However, it’s important to note that the Steelers didn’t bring Wilson to Pittsburgh just to sit on the bench and miss the chance to revive a career highlighted by two Super Bowl appearances.
Sure, Fields, 25, has shown he can be a solid and possibly long-term solution. He has cleverly avoided sacks behind a shaky offensive line, using his agility to escape pressure. He has made rival defenses cautious of run plays, which may not be as frequent with Wilson in charge. Plus, Fields has demonstrated good ball protection, with only one interception in five games and a pass efficiency rating of 97.1 that would be a personal best if it continues this season.
Nonetheless, Fields has shown some weaknesses, particularly in the recent 20-17 loss to the Dallas Cowboys, where his passing yards totaled just 131, with a maximum completion of 21 yards. The Steelers missed chances for big plays, as noted by Tomlin, leaving one to ponder how much more dynamic the Steelers’ offense could be with Wilson throwing the ball.
We’ll find out soon. As Fields took first-team snaps on Wednesday, it’s possible Tomlin won’t make any changes before their game against the Las Vegas Raiders on Sunday. There’s no urgency, and allowing Wilson extra healing time could be beneficial. It’s worth noting that Wilson returned to practice with the second team. Tomlin indicated, “We’re in a different phase now.”
Tomlin emphasized he won’t speculate on the timing for Wilson’s return to starting roles. One can understand his caution, given that the team believed Wilson was fully recovered at the end of preseason when he was named the starter. Then just three days before the opening game in Atlanta, he got injured again. The current process involves monitoring how Wilson’s calf responds to increased activity and whether it can withstand consecutive days of practice.
Still, Tomlin acknowledged, “The door is ajar” for a potential switch.
Speaking of possibilities, had Fields shown even better performance, like a 5-0 record with the NFL’s top-scoring offense, things might be different. However, that’s not the case right now. Wilson, who Tomlin said was in the “pole position” for the starting role when both quarterbacks joined in March, may not move as swiftly as he once did, or like Fields does now. Nevertheless, Tomlin certainly appreciates the experience that the 13-year veteran brings to crucial moments. If the team can support him with a strong running game (likely) and solid protection (less so), Wilson might be able to recapture some of the success he had during his prime with the Seattle Seahawks.
During a recent training camp session, Wilson expressed enthusiasm about Smith’s offense, highlighting its emphasis on the running game and play-action passing. If his previous performances are any indication, he should be capable of accurately throwing long passes, which have been lacking. This could inspire players, especially George Pickens, the talented receiver who has faced questions regarding his performance and attitude lately.
If Wilson is indeed that caliber of player, why were the Broncos quick to let him go? The Broncos are paying Wilson nearly $40 million this season, and even if their plans included drafting Bo Nix (selected 12th overall), they could have kept Wilson during the transition.
Or maybe not, as it would appear. Coach Sean Payton likely never fully embraced the quarterback he was given under difficult circumstances—or perhaps he just lost faith after trying him out last season. Regardless, it’s a fresh start.
This fresh start could also serve as an advantage for the Steelers. They might have a veteran who has a renewed sense of motivation. Tomlin has minimized this narrative, emphasizing that many players (and coaches) in the league are driven by extra motivation. This applies to Fields, acquired from the Chicago Bears, and also to Smith, who was released by the Atlanta Falcons.
In any case, Wilson stands on the edge of another significant opportunity. If he is no longer capable of playing at a high level, it will soon be apparent. With a chance to move to 4-2 this weekend, the Steelers have a reasonable option in Fields.
However, switching to Wilson could be an even better choice.