Recently, I shared my thoughts on social media, claiming that the struggles of the Pittsburgh Steelers cannot be attributed to Mike Tomlin. My views sparked quite a reaction, with comments labeling me as clueless, foolish, and more—thanks a lot, Mom!

Many Steelers fans reacted strongly, asserting I was mistaken. My main argument is that the real issue lies with the roster rather than Tomlin. Critics contend that Tomlin helps shape the roster and that he is losing his edge as a coach. This claim is laughable, and when you closely analyze the Steelers and compare their players to those of other playoff teams from this season, it becomes evident that Tomlin had limited resources to work with.

The idea that Tomlin has diminished in his coaching abilities is a popular narrative, as is the suggestion that the Steelers require a new voice. However, both notions are flawed. In the NFL, talent is crucial. While a skilled coach can enhance the potential of their players, there is a cap on what can be achieved without superior talent.

In past seasons, some early playoff exits might have been partly Tomlin’s fault. But this year, it’s clear that the team simply lacks sufficient receiving threats to pose any real danger. No coach could secure a strong performance with the current offense.

This isn’t about recognition from the Pro Bowl, which can be politically motivated and doesn’t always reflect a team’s actual talent. It’s based on my own observations and assessment.

It’s quite evident that the Steelers fielded the weakest roster among this year’s playoff contenders. In fact, in several instances, they were significantly outmatched.

Let’s break it down:

Vikings: While their quarterback situation may be uncertain, they boast a superstar in Justin Jefferson and talent throughout the roster. In contrast, the Steelers’ top offensive player is George Pickens, who often displays inconsistent dedication and punctuality.

While Tomlin has put up with similar behavior from players in the past, it shouldn’t fall on him to ensure that professional athletes act professionally.

Rams: Wide receiver Puka Nacua has immense potential. Their overall roster is clearly superior to the Steelers’.

Commanders: They have quarterback Jayden Daniels. Not much else to discuss here.

Lions: Seriously?

Kansas City: C’mon, they are in a different league.

Buccaneers: Baker Mayfield over Russell Wilson, coupled with a promising young running back group and the consistently impressive wide receiver Mike Evans.

Packers: We still assess quarterback Jordan Love, but the outlook is promising. Their receiving corps and an up-and-coming defense is better than Pittsburgh’s.

Eagles: Not even a comparison.

Chargers: This matchup is actually the closest. Justin Herbert has had his struggles in crucial moments, but he’s highly sought after by many general managers and coaches. Safety Derwin James is one of the league’s most underrated talents.

Speaking of James and the defensive aspect, Pittsburgh’s defense has significant issues. Are there schematic faults that Tomlin is responsible for? Sure. But star player T.J. Watt seemed to vanish during the last four games of the season, ending with no sacks, including the playoff matchup against the Ravens.

Texans: Wide receiver Nico Collins is an emerging superstar, and he’s not alone—there are several excellent pass catchers. Additionally, running back Joe Mixon outshines Najee “just a little over half a yard per carry” Harris.

Ravens: Not happening.

Broncos: Bo Nix is a franchise-caliber quarterback. Their defense (most of the time) mirrors the level the Steelers aspire to achieve.

Bills: LOL.

Hey there, you’re criticizing Pittsburgh’s roster, but Tomlin plays a role in shaping it, right?

Being involved does not mean having the ultimate authority.

In general, when Tomlin declares “the standard is the standard,” he’s referencing a bygone era. This “standard” applies to times when the Steelers had legends like Jerome Bettis, Ben Roethlisberger, and Troy Polamalu. Currently, they don’t possess even a fraction of that level of talent. Hines Ward isn’t coming back.

So, if you want to blame Tomlin, go right ahead. It’s your prerogative. But take a good look at the roster. Really examine it.

Is it really that impressive?

Is it?