A model created by an engineer at the University of Houston aims to improve the design of thin-walled structures such as planes, cars, and submersibles to prevent sudden collapse due to buckling.
When the Titan submersible experienced a catastrophic implosion last summer while carrying passengers to view the Titanic shipwreck, it served as a dramatic instance of the failure of a thin-walled structure. These types of incidents highlight the importance of designing these structures to avoid such collapses.
Structures, whether spherical or cylindrical, can effectively support large loads. However, their slender shape makes them vulnerable to collapsing due to buckling.
Submarines are not the only thin-walled structures you may encounter. Every time you get into a car or board a plane, you are interacting with one. While they may look flawless on paper, they often come out with geometric imperfections during manufacturing. These imperfections cause the structures to buckle under much smaller forces compared to if they were perfectly shaped.
rnrnUntil now, accurately predicting the harmful effects of geometric imperfections has been impossible. However, Roberto Ballarini, Thomas and Laura Hsu Professor and department chair of Civil and Environmental Engineering, is changing that. In the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), he reports a theoretical equation, based on computer simulations, that can predict the average buckling strength of a shell using parameters that describe the imperfections. Advanced math is involved in deriving these equations, allowing for the prediction of a structure’s resistance to buckling.According to Ballarini, the imperfections in the shapes and distribution of thin-walled load-bearing structures play a significant role in their buckling resistance. The equations derived from simulations can determine the average buckling resistance based on parameters describing these imperfections. The study was coauthored by Ballarini, doctoral student Zheren Baizhikova, and professor Jia-Liang Le from the University of Minnesota. The presence of localized deformation and randomly shaped imperfections are important characteristics of buckling type instabilities in these structures.It is generally accepted that the complex interactions of materials in response to mechanical loading are not yet fully understood, as demonstrated by buckling-induced catastrophic failures that still occur today,” the authors noted.
Ballarini also commented, “It’s important to remember that a structure’s ability to resist buckling failure is also influenced by the strength and stiffness of the material it’s made from.”
For example, consider the tragic failure of the Titan submersible.
“Its integrity may have been compromised by the damage to the material used for its hull that built up during the numerous trips it made before collapsing.The material used for the Titan’s hull was a carbon fiber composite. It is common knowledge that the fibers in these composites are prone to micro-buckling and delamination from the surrounding matrix when under compression. If the Titan’s hull suffered this kind of damage from the intense compressive pressures during its dives, it would have significantly reduced stiffness and strength. Combined with the inevitable imperfections from manufacturing, this may have led to its buckling-induced implosion,” Ballarini explained. Buckling begins in a shell at a certain point due to geometric flaws.The severity of imperfections is greatest in places where geometric imperfections are randomly distributed, which also means that the initial buckling zone is random.
Ballarini stated, “This randomness has significant implications for the statistics of the critical buckling pressure of the shell.” His computer simulations and theoretical analysis helped the research team create a probabilistic model for the statistical distribution of buckling resistance. This model shows potential for developing lightweight and sustainable structures while ensuring their structural reliability without unnecessary over-design.
Journal Reference