Germany’s Government in Turmoil: Calls for Early Election After Coalition Collapse
Chancellor Olaf Scholz dismissed his finance minister, leading to the breakdown of Germany’s government coalition on Wednesday.
BERLIN — Following the disintegration of Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s government coalition, opposition parties and business leaders in Germany are pushing for a swift new election to restore stability.
The coalition fractured on Wednesday when Scholz dismissed his finance minister amid escalating disagreements about addressing a major budget deficit and revitalizing the economy, which is entering its second consecutive year of decline.
This political upheaval creates a leadership void in the European Union, particularly as it looks to navigate challenges like Donald Trump’s recent election as U.S. president, which raises concerns over potential trade tariffs and ongoing issues related to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and NATO’s future.
Scholz plans to conduct a confidence vote in January, which he is likely to lose, thereby prompting an election by the end of March, six months earlier than intended.
Friedrich Merz, the leader of the conservative opposition party, has called for a confidence vote “by early next week at the latest,” a sentiment that other opposition leaders support.
He indicated that elections could be held as soon as late January.
“Germany cannot afford to have a government without a majority for several months, followed by an extended election campaign and possibly more weeks of coalition negotiations,” Merz stated to the media.
German industry, grappling with high expenses and stiff competition from Asia, also urged the government to expedite the election process.
This political uncertainty led to a spike in German borrowing costs, with the 10-year yield rising up to 10 basis points, reaching its highest level since July, while an important market risk indicator dropped to a record low.
Scholz postponed his departure for the EU summit in Budapest amid the crisis and canceled his attendance at the upcoming UN climate change summit.
Challenges for Scholz in Securing Conservative Support
Scholz, from the center-left Social Democrats (SPD), stated he dismissed Finance Minister Christian Lindner of the fiscally conservative Free Democrats (FDP) due to his obstruction in resolving budget disagreements.
The final straw was Lindner’s refusal to back Scholz’s proposal to relax debt limits in order to allocate $3.25 billion to support Ukraine in the 2025 budget.
Lindner’s exit from the coalition prompted the FDP to withdraw, placing Scholz’s SPD and the Greens in a minority government position, relying on fragile alliances for passing significant legislation.
A meeting between Scholz and Merz on Thursday did not yield any solutions, according to a government source.
Joerg Kukies, a senior official in the chancellery and a close ally of Scholz from the SPD, is expected to be appointed as the new finance minister.
This crisis hits Germany at a particularly precarious moment, with a stagnant economy, aging infrastructure, and a military that is ill-prepared. Economists warn it could negatively affect consumption and investment in the coming months, especially with Trump’s return potentially undermining exports.
The FDP’s withdrawal indicates a loss for the government’s transatlantic initiative, which has been focused on strengthening relationships with senior U.S. Republicans in anticipation of Trump’s possible return to the presidency.
Despite the turmoil, some experts suggest that this crisis might ultimately be beneficial, citing the persistent struggles within the coalition, which is unprecedented at the federal level.
ING economist Carsten Brzeski noted, “New elections and a fresh government could end the current stagnation and provide clarity in policy direction.”
However, the rise of populist parties—both left and right—in Germany and throughout Europe indicates that even a new election may not guarantee a straightforward coalition with a stable majority.
Economy Minister Robert Habeck from the Greens remarked, “It’s clear that things won’t necessarily get easier, even after the next election.”